Newsweek Writer Uses Phony Statistics to Support Gun Violence Report
Writer Ryan Bort has been caught red handed promoting phony “gun violence” statistics in a recent #FakeNews story for (the failing) Newsweek, claiming that guns are now the third leading cause of death for children. The story seems to be based around a report by a journal called Pediatrics, but Bort never actually provides a link to the report that he continually references. Instead, he gives links to the CDC and another organization called National Electronic Injury Surveillance System (NEISS), which the Pediatrics article supposedly sourced for their report.
There’s just one problem for Mr. Bort; His numbers are all wrong. And it’s not even close.
He says that “Data on fatal gun deaths were drawn from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s National Vital Statistics System database, and data on non-fatal gun injuries were from the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission’s National Electronic Injury Surveillance System” so we’ll use those data sets instead of Bort’s #AlternativeFacts. The actual CDC report from 2014, the most recent available, can be found HERE.
Bort says “A study published Monday in the journal Pediatrics showed that an average of 5,790 children in the United States receive emergency room treatment for gun-related injuries each year”
The report from NEISS doesn’t even list firearm injuries for children. However, the NEISS report DOES list several causes of injury that outpace this mysterious 5,790 number. This includes nursery equipment, which injures over 75,000 children a year; Toys, at nearly 180,000; “Stairs, Ramps, Landings, Floors” lead the way with 525,000 injuries per year; Others that rank in the hundreds of thousands include football, tables, ladders, bedding, chairs and sofas, playground equipment, basketball, and bicycles – Even “sound recording equipment” manages to injure 8,000 children a year.
The closest thing that the NEISS report lists to actual guns are “Nonpowder Guns, BB’S, Pellets”, which injured about 9,000 kids in 2014. These are toy guns.
Mr. Bort says his numbers are “based on data taken from 2012–2014 for children up to the age of 17.” Except these data sets don’t have a cutoff at 17. They are listed from 0-4 and 5-14, and 15-24, both in the NIESS report and the CDC report.
Ryan Bort also makes the claim that “An average of 1,297 children die annually from gun-related injuries, making guns the third-leading cause of death for children in America (behind illnesses and unintentional injuries like drownings or car crashes).”
This is completely untrue. According to the CDC report that Bort himself links to, a total of 459 children ages 0-14 died in 2014 by use of a firearm. This is barely 1/3 of his mythical 1,297 figure. Again, he may be relying on stats that include children up to 17, which are seemingly not possible to extract.
His overall premise of guns being the “third-leading cause of death for children in America” is also completely untrue, and it’s not even close. Here are the top causes of child death, ages 0-14, per the CDC 2014 report:
- “Certain conditions originating in the perinatal period”, 11,895
- “Congenital malformations, deformations and chromosomal abnormalities”, 5,493
- “Symptoms, signs and abnormal clinical and laboratory findings, not elsewhere classified”, 3019
- “All other diseases”, 1846
“Other and unspecified non-transport accidents and their sequelae”, 1427
- Transport accidents, 1302
- “Malignant neoplasms” (cancer), 1225
- Cardiovascular diseases, 903
- “Assault (homicide) by other and unspecified means and their sequelae”, 667
- Accidental drowning, 647
- All firearm related death combined, 459
As a percentage, all firearm related death combined accounts for 1.42% of all child deaths.
Bort’s also stated that “Researchers found that 53 percent of the gun-related deaths were homicides, while 38 percent were suicides, 6 percent were unintentional and 3 percent were related to law enforcement or undetermined causes.” Once again, completely untrue, be it general firearm deaths for all age ranges or as they apply only to children.
If he’s referring to all age ranges, the CDC lists suicide by firearms at 21,386 for 2014, and homicide by firearm at 11,008. So homicide by firearm accounts for roughly 35% of the overall firearm deaths, not 53% . If Bort is referring to children, the 2014 report lists homicides at 225 and overall gun related deaths at 459. So, less than 50% . Furthermore, with 49 negligent discharges to 459 overall gun related deaths for children, that’s about 9% , not 6% .
You may recall a story last year on The Gateway Pundit that analyzed the 2013 CDC report, which somehow managed to escape the anti gun organizations’ attention. Maybe because it doesn’t fit their narrative.
Perhaps Mr. Ryan Bort should spend some time vetting the studies that he references for his articles.